The Debates

North American Economy

The Debate

As stock markets gyrate, Europe lurches from crisis to crisis, and U.S. recovery slows, the future of the North American economy is more uncertain than ever.

Can individual entrepreneurship, corporate innovation and governments create a new era of sustained economic growth? Or, will the financial crisis, U.S. political dysfunction, and the rise of emerging nations erode our living standards for the long term? Fundamentally, will the next generation of North Americans enjoy the same quality of life as its parents?

To promote a far-ranging discussion of an issue critical to every Canadian, the 8th semi-annual Munk Debate convenes four big thinkers to tackle the resolution:

Be it resolved North America faces a Japan-style era of economic stagnation.

Pro

Paul Krugman

Paul Krugman

It’s now impossible to deny the obvious, which is that we are not now and have never been on the road to recovery.
David Rosenberg

David Rosenberg

When all the stimulus is gone and the Emperor is disrobed, it is not going to be a pretty picture.

Con

Lawrence Summers

Lawrence Summers

The American people have not become less dedicated to hard work, and the productive potential of this economy has not declined.
Ian Bremmer

Ian Bremmer

North America’s long-term prospects are brighter than Europe’s or Japan’s; the "rise of the rest" does not automatically imply our decline.

Debate Results

PRE-DEBATE
PRO: 56%  CON:26%
UNDECIDED:18%

POST-DEBATE
PRO: 55%  CON: 45%

Watch the debate

You must be a Premium Member to view this content. Login/Signup.

Debate Transcript

You must be a Premium or Basic Member to view this content. Login/Signup.

Debate Audio.mp3

You must be a Premium Member to view this content. Login/Signup.