The Debates

Healthcare

The Debate

Do ballooning healthcare spending, evermore expensive prescription drugs and an increased use of private medicine foreshadow the wholesale reform of Canada’s universal, single-payer system? Or, are the divisive debates, social inequities, and sky-high expenditures associated with the U.S. experience with private medicine a validation of Canada’s universal Medicare system?

To encourage a far-ranging discussion of one of the great policy unknowns facing Canadians – the future of our healthcare system – the 5th semi-annual Munk Debate will debate the resolution:

Pro

Dr. William Frist

Dr. William Frist

America has the best doctors, the best nurses, the best hospitals, the best medical technology, the best medical breakthrough medicines in the world.
Dr. David Gratzer

Dr. David Gratzer

Yes, everyone in Canada is covered by a “single payer” – the government. But Canadians wait for practically any procedure or diagnostic test or specialist.

Con

Dr. Howard Dean

Dr. Howard Dean

Every single industrialized country on the face of the earth has health insurance for all of its people. Why can’t we have what all those countries have?
Dr. Robert Bell

Dr. Robert Bell

Why would we create the inefficiencies and inequities associated with private funding, rather than simply leverage the efficient public system?

Debate Results

PRE-DEBATE
PRO: 23%  CON:70%
UNDECIDED:7%

POST-DEBATE
PRO: 23%  CON: 77%

Watch the debate

You must be a Premium Member to view this content. Login/Signup.

Debate Transcript

You must be a Premium or Basic Member to view this content. Login/Signup.

Debate Audio.mp3

You must be a Premium Member to view this content. Login/Signup.