Select Another Debate

Iran's Nuclear Ambitions

Be it resolved the world cannot tolerate an Iran with nuclear weapons capability...

 

November 26, 2012

It has been rightly characterized as the toughest foreign policy challenge in a generation: how should the world respond to Iran’s nuclear ambitions? For some, the case for a preemptive strike on Iran is ironclad. An Iranian bomb would flood the volatile Middle East with nuclear weapons and trap Israel in a state of perilous insecurity—along with much of the world’s oil supply. Others argue that a nuclear Iran could be the very stabilizing force that the region needs, as the threat of nuclear war makes conventional conflicts more risky. These same voices also ask: can the West and Israel afford to attack Iran when doing so could rollback the Arab Spring and re-entrench reactionary forces throughout the Middle East?

The tenth Munk Debate will tackle these game-changing issues by moving the motion: Be it resolved the world cannot tolerate an Iran with nuclear weapons capability.

Debate Results

Pre-Debate Results

60% Pro 24% Con

Post-Debate Results

58% Pro 42% Con

CON gains 18%. CON wins

Debaters

Pro

Amos Yadlin

“There is no hotline between Tel Aviv and Tehran, and no other stabilizing mechanisms between us and the Iranians, so the danger of an unplanned nuclear confrontation is significant. ”

Read bio

Pro

Charles Krauthammer

“Deterring Iran is fundamentally different from deterring the Soviet Union. You could rely on the latter but not on the former.”

Read bio

Con

Fareed Zakaria

“Iran has not surrendered, and Israel seems to view any other scenario as unacceptable. ”

Read bio

Con

Vali Nasr

“As for attempting to rein in Iran, that could prove both counterproductive and unnecessary.”

Read bio

Media download options

Munk Debate members have access to past debate media downloads. Premium and Video members have access to all VIDEO, TRANSCRIPTS and PODCAST downloads. And Basic members have access to TRANSCRIPTS of the debates.

Become a member now Member Login

Video Highlights

Expert Opinions

Press Releases

Image Gallery

Comments

comments powered by Disqus